Federal Circuit Upholds TTAB Decision: “Everybody vs Racism” Phrase Denied Trademark Status

The U.S. Federal Circuit has upheld a refusal from the U.S. Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB) to register the phrase “Everybody vs Racism” as a trademark. According to the Federal Circuit, the phrase is considered to be widely used and does not pinpoint a singular source. Such a conclusion has reaffirmed the underlying principle in trademark law, which stipulates that trademarks serve as unique identifiers clearly linking products or services to a particular source.

The TTAB, the administrative board dealing with matters relating to tradename registrations and disputes, in its original decision, expressed a fundamental trademark rule: common use phrases in the public domain cannot be monopolized by a select few as trademarks. TTAB found the mark to be used widely in various walks of everyday life, from social campaigns to merchandises, thus deeming it unfit for trademark protection.

Registering commonly used phrases can put unnecessary restrictions on the freedom of expression and could additionally create undesired monopolies over such expressions. Whether the refusal of registration will discourage other attempts to trademark commonly used phrases remains to be seen but for now, the ruling carries a significant message about the intended purpose and function of trademarks.

For more in-depth analysis about the case, visit Law360.