The Judicial Conference of the US’s Committee on Judicial Conduct and Disability has made a controversial decision in the Newman case. Long-standing Federal Circuit judge, Pauline Newman, has been kept from fulfilling her duties due to allegations that she “may suffer from a disability that prevents her from discharging the duties of office.” According to Bloomberg Law, the evidence presented includes affidavits and a collection of her previous emails suggesting cognitive issues such as memory loss and confusion.
Crucially, the focus of the concern in this case is procedural, not merely the charges brought against Newman. The Committee found that Newman did not provide any evidence of bias from the judges on the Federal Circuit’s Judicial Council, thereby disallowing her request to transfer the case. It was also concluded that Newman’s demand to condition her cooperation with the investigation on the granting of her transfer request was not permissible.
Evidence from the accusing party that suggested Newman had a heart attack and had stents put in were categorically denied by Newman herself in an interview with Above The Law. Repeated misinterpretations of health results by the accuser have also added fuel to the fire of this contentious case.
Many see Newman’s suspension as an underhanded and unconstitutional method to remove undesirable members from the panel. Some critics argue that the Convocation’s decision essentially sanctions circumvention of the procedural protections defined by the Constitution.
Thankfully, this won’t be the last decision made in Newman’s case. Her lawyer, Greg Dolin of the New Civil Liberties Alliance, voiced their intention to continue pressing their claims. A lawsuit is ongoing at the US District Court for the District of Columbia where Judge Newman is challenging the constitutionality of the Judicial Conduct and Disability Act that led to her being investigated. The team is prepared to take the case to the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia and the US Supreme Court, if deemed necessary.
Newman’s case stands as a stark reminder of the importance of strict adherence to due process in any legal proceedings, particularly in those directly impacting the judiciary. The outcome could potentially influence future proceedings, which brings an added layer of importance to the case.
Further reading can be found in an article detailing Pauline Newman’s doctor’s thoughts on the panel ruling against her, as well as in this detailed report on the entire case.