Combating Tax Evasion: State Revenue Departments Must Act Proactively in Addressing Electronic Sales Suppression

State Departments of Revenue need to rethink their strategies in the battle against tax evasion, more explicitly, the sort that is facilitated by electronic sales suppression tools. Burying their heads in the sand and relying entirely upon post-hoc enforcement to identify and thwart the usage of these tools leaves the proverbial barn door wide open, allowing horses to escape at will.

The war against tax evasion has turned more sophisticated in recent decades with the advent of sales tax “zappers”, a type of electronic sales suppression software designed to manipulate sales records to dodge remitting collected sales tax. Just last December, Wisconsin became the latest of over 30 states to criminalize the usage of these tax evasion tools (source) .

This issue is not isolated. A case in Connecticut in 2023 (source), wherein a restaurant owner was sentenced for a $2 million fraud involving such a zapper, underscores the severity of the problem. As state revenues decline, states will undoubtedly need to amplify their efforts to uncover tax evasion schemes and hold perpetrators accountable.

As they embark on this journey, state departments of revenue should not neglect their duty to inform the public alongside clamping down on fraudulent tools usage. These departments should enhance transparency by publicly listing dubious point-of-sale software, paralleling the IRS’s approach of listing known tax shelters as listed transactions (source).

The existence of a zapper for any given POS system can spur increased scrutiny by state departments of revenue. A more transparent and compliant business environment can be cultivated by state revenue departments proactively maintaining and making public lists of POS systems under investigation for facilitating tax evasion via zappers or other such tools.

Just as the IRS maintains its listed transactions, state revenue departments should likewise furnish lists of POS systems found to contain, or have available, corresponding zappers or electronic sales suppression tools. This would not mean an end to audits or investigations, but rather encourage businesses to avoid engaging with problematic systems and incorporate practices that ensure better compliance.

It’s also essential to reflect upon the fact that possession of a zapper does not necessarily infer usage for fraud. Such software may have legitimate primary uses that are unrelated to tax evasion. Penalizing an owner simply because their POS system software could be used to alter transactional records can lead to undue targeting.

State revenue departments can build a bridge of trust with the wider business community by fostering transparency. This way, businesses can feel more supported in their endeavors to comply with tax laws. Ultimately, the call for listed software to be provided to business owners by state revenue departments is a call for a more collaborative approach to tax compliance.

Andrew Leahey, a tax and technology attorney, principal at Hunter Creek Consulting, and adjunct professor at Drexel Kline School of Law, emphasizes this view. For more on these insights, visit the Technically Speaking column (source) on Bloomberg Tax.