The New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS) has issued an advisory directive as of January 22, encouraging banks to thoroughly vet the “character and fitness” of their top leadership personnel. Given the recent corporate failures, including the bankruptcy of various crypto exchanges and bank busts, it’s crucial that financial institutions take this advice seriously. The guidance, whilst only advisory at this stage, could soon evolve into binding legislation.
This directive applies not just to banking organizations within New York, but also to the branches, agencies, and foreign banking organizations licensed by the DFS, as well as non-depository financial establishments governed under the New York Banking Law. The directive is broad-reaching, applying to board directors, C-suite, and other high-ranking officers within these organizations.
The DFS even provides specific questions to use during the vetting process, covering issues such as indebtedness, lobbying activities, histories of litigation, past regulatory investigations, tax payment records, employment termination histories, and more. With the objective of maintaining a high standard of leadership, the guidance advocates for a periodical revisiting of these evaluations, not limiting it to the point of hiring.
DFS’s move towards stricter executive evaluation can be seen as a reaction to recent setbacks, such as the seizure of Signature Bank in March 2023. The importance of robust corporate governance is underlined by the emerging financial struggles apparent in the case of this seizure and consequential report which pointed to “emerging weaknesses in corporate governance”.
The recent upheavals in the corporate sector and the poignant tensions within the banking-crypto intersection, may push politicians and regulators to enforce stricter compliance requirements on notably financial institutions. Any gaps in the vetting process within banks, crypto exchanges, and other financial organizations should be addressed urgently, given the precedents set by high-profile criminal prosecutions of FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried and Celsius CEO Alex Mashinsky.
While organizations might view the DFS guidance as optional, and strictly advisory in nature, it is crucial that they patch up loopholes in their vetting policies and adhere as closely to these guidelines as possible. Adopting these standards could save larger corporations from ensuing regulatory challenges and provide a robust framework to ensure competent leadership at the helm.
Read more in the detailed report at Bloomberg Law.