The National Rifle Association’s (NRA) 2017 launch of Carry Guard insurance was aimed at providing liability protection for gun owners. It was designed to cover the cost of legal fees and court costs for incidents where harm was caused using the insured weapon. However, the product was quickly targeted by state regulators due to concerns over insuring intentional criminal acts.
In 2018 and 2019, New York State Department of Financial Services, under the leadership of Superintendent Maria Vullo, launched an investigation into the product. This led to three insurance entities that supported Carry Guard paying more than $13 million in fines. The NRA itself agreed to a $2.5 million penalty in 2021.
Instead of accepting their lapse, the NRA has taken the issue to the US Supreme Court, with arguments scheduled for March 18. They claim that Vullo’s actions have caused them difficulties in obtaining corporate insurance coverage, and are calling for her actions to be nullified, citing an extreme interpretation of the First Amendment to justify their stance.
However, the Second Circuit held unanimously that the NRA didn’t have a valid First Amendment case, seeing Vullo’s actions as an expression of government’s policy positions and not as a threat or coercion. If the NRA and their allied American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) succeed in this case, it could open up a series of claims against the government securing industries super-privileged legal status.
The case, National Rifle Association of America v. Vullo, represents a chance for the court to draw a definitive line against what is seen by some as an attempt to undermine regulatory powers.