DOJ Whistleblower Program: Learning from Predecessors and Addressing Current Flaws

The U.S. Department of Justice’s (DOJ) whistleblower reward program for corporate and financial misconduct, as unveiled by Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco on March 7th, has not been exempted from critical assessments. Drawing inspiration from preceding successful whistleblower programs, the DOJ has highlighted the usefulness of these initiatives, however, it also reveals several inadequacies in its current form. A number of key adjustments are necessary to align DOJ’s approach with the established successes observed in the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission whistleblower programs, according to Monaco.[1]

First and foremost, the need for a central whistleblower office to accept anonymous and confidential complaints is paramount. Anonymous and confidential reporting has formed the backbone of the success achieved by the Dodd-Frank programs, ensuring whistleblowers are shielded from potential retaliation risks.[2] Despite this, the DOJ has so far failed to set up such reporting channels, a requirement established under the Anti-Money Laundering Act, passed in 2021.

Another noteworthy flaw in DOJ’s whistleblower award program is the ineligibility of individuals who have participated in the underlying misconduct. This disregards the fact that whistleblowers are often players within the machinations of these malpractices and therefore, hold crucial information. This dismissal of key potential sources of evidence and information lacks alignment with the principles that have made whistleblower laws successful. Such laws, like the False Claims Act[3], understand that those participating in wrongdoing are often the best witnesses.

The shortcomings of DOJ’s program do not end there. Additionally, it does not address all forms of violations, and its proposed solutions need a closer look. With inadequate award provisions and a complex political approval process that may undermine the incentivization of whistleblowers, the current framework of the law is far from sufficient. Additionally, the program denies whistleblowers the right to challenge a denial of an award in a court of law, thereby denying them due process.

The solution lies in improving measures and provisions under the current laws. Implementation of a mandatory anonymous reporting process for money laundering disclosures is but the first step in this direction. As such, although the DOJ acknowledges the successes of the Dodd-Frank programs and intends to reward whistleblowers, its handling of whistleblowing cases needs a revamp. Only with a serious reconsideration of these elements can the DOJ ensure that its program is successfully implemented.[4]

Stephen M. Kohn, a founding partner of whistleblower law firm Kohn, Kohn & Colapinto, contributed to this article, alongside Geoff Schweller.