Independent Cybersecurity Audits: Essential Tools in Navigating New Regulatory Landscape for Boards

In the face of rising personal liability concerns for board members, independent cybersecurity audits are proving to be powerful tools in organizational governance. They are essential in manifesting leadership, pinpointing potential weaknesses, and complying with regulations that hold the board and C-suite to account for their company’s cybersecurity program.

New rulings such as the Securities and Exchange Commission’s 2023 rules on cybersecurity risk governance are pushing for dynamic demonstration of compliance. They require boardroom executives to showcase active oversight of their corporations’ cybersecurity management and to bear personal liability for any failures. Under these rules, public reporting companies have a series of prerequisites. These requirements include making known all materials related to cybersecurity incidents within a four-day window and describing their processes for identifying, assessing, and combating material risks instigated by cyber threats.

The amended cybersecurity regulation by the New York State Department of Financial Services is another recent example. Including cybersecurity as part of business strategy, it demands for covered entities the conducting of independent audits of their cybersecurity programmes. Enhanced requirements include more frequent risk assessments, stricter incident response preparations, and more resilient business continuity and disaster recovery plans.

These two new regulations demonstrate the increasing oversight of company cybersecurity practices and disclosures. These approaches have paved the way for similar regulations at both state and federal level across the USA. Consequently, cybersecurity audits are set to become an even larger part of the regulatory obligations of companies.

Auditing processes are far from a one-size-fits-all solution and need to be tailored to each company. An effective cybersecurity audit will include four main phases: defining the scope of data collection, running the cybersecurity audit, validating audit findings and lastly, presenting the final audit report to the company’s leadership. An independent auditor who is well-versed with the systems and business flow of the company can help keep these processes efficient and effective.

Auditing is a multi-step process starting with defining the scope of the audit, collecting documents and questionnaires and running stakeholder interviews. It proceeds to assessing a firm’s compliance with cybersecurity regulations and standards, interviewing stakeholders, running risk assessments, and performing on-site inspections, among other tasks. The result should be a draft memo summarizing the findings of the cybersecurity audit, and suggesting solutions to the identified problems.

Lastly, it’s crucial for companies to derive as much insight as possible from these audits to identify potential cybersecurity risks and act prudently. Board members can use the data and tools provided by these audits to gauge any cyber risks their companies may face. Independent cybersecurity audits thus play a crucial role in ensuring the cybersecurity of organizations and help board members in exercising their leadership roles more effectively.

This article has been adapted from an original piece by Daniel B. Garrie and Anna Diaz Gessner.

Read Daniel B. Garrie’s and Anna Diaz Gessner’s full analysis.