Supreme Court Refuses to Intervene in Lawsuit Against Black Lives Matter Organizer

The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to step in on a lawsuit lodged by a Louisiana police officer against Black Lives Matter organizer DeRay Mckesson. Mckesson had organized a protest during which the officer sustained severe injuries. This reconsideration refusal for Mckesson v. Doe was part of the justices recent list of orders.

The central question here was whether Mckesson should be held accountable for the officer’s injuries despite not inflicting them directly. Instead, he was the event coordinator and, as per the officer, “knew or should have known” the possible ensuing violence.

This lawsuit saw the Supreme Court in 2019 when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit permitted the officer’s litigation to proceed. Mckesson then appealed to the Supreme Court, pressuring for lawsuit protection under the First Amendment and the Supreme Court’s 1982 decision in NAACP v. Claiborne Hardware Co.. This past decision curtailed the NAACP’s liability for a peaceful protest they organized.

In 2020, the court redirected the case to the 5th Circuit instructing them to consult the Louisiana Supreme Court about whether state law indeed allowed Mckesson to be held reliable. After the Louisiana Supreme Court’s response insinuating a protest leader’s potential negligence lawsuit, the divided 5th Circuit provided a renewed opinion enabling the litigation to continue.

Despite seven consecutive conferences considering the case, the Supreme Court declined to review it, with a statement by Justice Sonia Sotomayor acknowledging the decision.

She pointed out that since the appeals court’s decision, the Supreme Court in Counterman v. Colorado made clear that the First Amendment prohibits the use of an objective standard like negligence for penalizing speech. It also established the requirement of intent in Claiborne and other incitement cases.

Other reviews were also declined by the justices, such as the case of Kurt Michaels and Dillion Compton, causing dissents from Justices Sotomayor and Brown Jackson. The next private session for the justices is scheduled for April 19.

This report was initially featured by the SCOTUSblog and penned down by Amy Howe. To get more in-depth coverage of the story, you can read the full article SCOTUSblog.