Seventh Circuit Affirms Denial of Attorney’s Fees in Trademark Case Involving Hong Kong Retailer Lightzey

The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the denial of attorney’s fees to Lightzey, a Hong Kong-based online retailer, in a trademark infringement case initiated by Danish lighting manufacturer Louis Poulsen A/S. The court determined that Louis Poulsen’s erroneous inclusion of Lightzey in the lawsuit did not constitute an “exceptional” circumstance warranting fee reimbursement.

Louis Poulsen filed a “Schedule A” lawsuit under the Lanham Act, targeting 436 e-commerce retailers, including Lightzey, for alleged trademark counterfeiting and infringement. The Northern District of Illinois granted an ex parte temporary restraining order (TRO), freezing the defendants’ online financial accounts. Lightzey was subsequently dismissed from the suit after providing evidence that it had not sold infringing products to consumers in the United States, including Illinois. Following its dismissal, Lightzey sought attorney’s fees under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a), which the district court denied.

In its decision, the Seventh Circuit acknowledged that, in hindsight, there was no basis for exercising specific personal jurisdiction over Lightzey in Illinois. However, the court emphasized that Louis Poulsen’s mistake did not rise to the level of “exceptional” conduct necessary to justify an award of attorney’s fees. The court noted that Louis Poulsen had a reasonable, albeit mistaken, belief that it could bring Lightzey into Illinois federal court, and upon realizing the error, promptly dismissed Lightzey from the case.

This ruling underscores the challenges associated with “Schedule A” cases, where plaintiffs often include numerous defendants based on limited initial information. The court’s decision suggests that inadvertent errors in such cases do not automatically lead to fee awards unless the plaintiff’s conduct is deemed exceptional.

Legal professionals should be aware of the complexities involved in multi-defendant trademark infringement cases and the importance of thoroughly verifying jurisdictional grounds before initiating legal action. This case serves as a reminder that while plaintiffs must diligently protect their intellectual property, they must also exercise caution to avoid unnecessary litigation against parties over whom the court lacks jurisdiction.