In a crucial development on Tuesday, the full Federal Circuit overruled established metrics used to determine if design patents could be invalidated as obvious. The court characterized these norms as “improperly rigid”, and instead directed that the test for utility patents, typically used to examine if a patent’s claims are obvious, should be applied in such events.
The court’s decision essentially displaces long-standing tests for appraising design patents, which had so far been used as a benchmark in identifying clear cases of patent invalidity owing to obviousness of the design. The shift in approach towards the use of the obviousness test used for utility patents signifies a significant change in the patent legal processes.
For more information on the Federal Circuit’s decision and an in-depth understanding of its implications, you can review the original report on the matter here.