A feces-encrusted swim diaper resold by Amazon has ruptured a family business, Bloomberg reports, leading to a negative review that demolished a million-dollar enterprise, leaving it in a $600,000 debt. Paul and Rachelle Baron, owners of Beau & Belle Littles, revealed that Amazon failed to inspect the returned item before reselling it, consequently generating a one-star review in 2020 that over a hundred customers found “helpful.”
“The diaper arrived used and was covered in poop stains,” the review stated, showcasing images of the item. The review’s increased visibility occurred as the Barons aimed to triple their annual sales to $3 million. Despite numerous five-star reviews, the negative feedback persistently plagued the business, the couple said.
Amazon prohibits reviews focusing on seller, order, or shipping issues rather than the item’s quality, but declined to remove this review. The review blamed the seller for Amazon’s inspection oversight. The teacher who posted the review, Erin Elizabeth Herbert, told Bloomberg she intended to revise her review but had not done so due to a busy schedule.
“I always meant to go back and revise my review to reflect that, and life got busy and I never did,” Herbert said to Bloomberg.
Amazon spokesperson Maria Boschetti told Bloomberg, “We are sorry to hear that a seller feels their return was not evaluated correctly and resulted in a negative review,” emphasizing that sellers can raise concerns and that Amazon listens to feedback to improve the selling experience.
Other sellers have also complained about Amazon’s failure to remove reviews that violate community guidelines. The Barons are now selling enough inventory to pay down their debt but struggle to make a living. They secured a loan with their home, complicating bankruptcy prospects, and have taken on additional jobs.
“The last four years have been an emotional train wreck,” Paul Baron told Bloomberg. He added, “Shoppers might think returning a poopy diaper to Amazon is a victimless way to get their money back, but we’re a small, family business, and this is how we pay our mortgage.”