In a remarkable legal decision, Judge Aileen Cannon has ruled that Special Counsel Jack Smith’s appointment to investigate former President Donald Trump was unconstitutional. This decision challenges several established Supreme Court precedents regarding the Appointments Clause and could have significant implications for ongoing and future investigations involving high-profile figures.
Judge Cannon’s ruling hinges on the interpretation that Special Counsel Smith’s appointment violates the Appointments Clause of the Constitution because it was not confirmed by the Senate. The judge argues that the power to appoint such officials should rest with Congress and not be delegated solely to the Attorney General. The Appointments Clause is designed to maintain the separation of powers and ensure Congressional oversight of significant appointments within the Department of Justice.
Addressing the language of 28 U.S. Code § 515, which allows for the Attorney General to appoint special attorneys, Judge Cannon asserts that this provision does not authorize the initial appointment of a Special Counsel. Rather, it is an administrative statute guiding the duties of attorneys “already appointed” to special roles. Judge Cannon’s interpretation departs from the understanding used by other courts and legal scholars, who have generally accepted that § 515 implicitly grants appointment authority to the Attorney General.
Further complicating the matter, Judge Cannon questioned the funding mechanism for the Special Counsel’s office. Currently, funds are allocated from an indefinite appropriation meant to protect the integrity of independent investigations by ensuring they cannot be defunded by Congress. However, Judge Cannon concluded that without a lawful basis for the Special Counsel’s appointment, the funding itself is not legitimately appropriated.
This decision arrives amidst a backdrop of contentious legal battles involving former President Trump, who has been under scrutiny for allegedly mishandling classified documents and other investigations by the Special Counsel. Observers note that the arguments invoked by Trump in Washington, D.C., were dismissed outright by other judges, including in the case of former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort. Yet, Judge Cannon’s ruling diverges sharply from this judicial consensus.
The ruling raises profound questions about the future of Special Counsels in the U.S. legal system and could significantly impact the ability of the Department of Justice to conduct independent investigations, particularly those involving high-ranking officials or politically sensitive matters. Legal experts and scholars will undoubtedly be scrutinizing this decision, its interpretation of the Appointments Clause, and its potential effects on the rule of law in democratic governance.
For a detailed look at the court documents and background on the case, visit the Court Listener page for United States v. Trump. Additional coverage is available on Above the Law.