A recent lawsuit filed by ABM Industry Groups LLC, a janitorial and cleaning services contractor, has cast a spotlight on the legality of the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs’ (OFCCP) use of administrative law judges. The company argues that this mechanism violates its Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial, a claim that draws upon the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in SEC v. Jarkesy. In that case, the Court questioned the constitutionality of certain administrative processes used by federal agencies.
The contractor contends that the OFCCP’s administrative procedure is akin to common law breaches of contract, which historically qualify for a jury trial. This legal maneuver underscores the firm’s broader constitutional concerns and suggests that the Department of Labor’s approach to enforcing civil rights compliance among federal contractors may face significant legal challenges ahead.
Regardless of the outcome, a loss in the courts would not completely eliminate the OFCCP’s capacity for enforcement. However, it could prompt a significant reassessment of how such cases are adjudicated, potentially including a shift towards more traditional judicial processes involving juries.
For more information, you can access the full article on Bloomberg Law’s website.