Supreme Court’s Stance on International Law: Implications of the ‘Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D.’ Decision

In a case indicative of the U.S. Supreme Court’s current approach to international law, the court recently sided with the Trump administration by granting a stay in Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D.. This decision allows for the deportation of undocumented individuals to third countries without the opportunity for them to demonstrate that they might face torture or persecution there.

The policy in question depends on “diplomatic assurances” from receiving states that deportees will not be harmed, a practice criticized as insufficient under international law, particularly by the UN Committee Against Torture and other international bodies (UNHCR). These criticisms stress the importance of procedural protections, like notice and the ability to contest removal, to uphold obligations under treaties like the 1951 Refugee Convention and the 1987 Convention Against Torture.

The district court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit found that U.S. statutes such as the Immigration and Nationality Act and the Foreign Affairs Reform and Restructuring Act implicitly require such procedural safeguards. Notably, the concept of non-refoulement, or not returning individuals to places where they risk serious harm, is both a treaty obligation and a principle of customary international law endorsed by the U.S. Congress when it ratified these treaties (U.S. legal doctrine bibliography).

In denying these procedural safeguards, the Supreme Court seems to sideline its predecessors’ wisdom, including Chief Justice John Marshall’s 1804 Charming Betsy decision, which advised against interpreting statutes in ways that conflict with international law. As the U.S.’s legal system continues to grapple with these issues, the interplay between domestic and international obligations remains a crucial area of concern for practitioners and policymakers alike. More details on this topic can be found in the full analysis on SCOTUSblog.