The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has affirmed the dismissal of patent infringement lawsuits filed by Touchmusic Entertainment LLC and its successor, Ziklag IP LLC, against technology companies including Apple Inc., Amazon Web Services, Inc., and Netflix, Inc. The court’s decisions, issued on November 19, 2026, centered on the plaintiffs’ lack of standing to sue for past damages related to an expired patent.
Touchmusic initiated litigation in March 2024, alleging that Apple, Amazon, and Netflix infringed U.S. Patent No. 6,182,128, which pertains to real-time music distribution systems. Notably, this patent had expired on March 5, 2018. At the time of filing, Touchmusic’s corporate rights were suspended under California law, rendering it incapable of initiating legal action. To circumvent this issue, Touchmusic assigned certain rights of the ‘128 patent to the newly formed Ziklag IP LLC in April 2024, which then substituted as the plaintiff in the lawsuits.
In the cases against Apple and Amazon, the district court determined that Ziklag did not possess the right to sue for past damages—a critical factor given the patent’s expiration. Consequently, the court dismissed the cases with prejudice. On appeal, the Federal Circuit upheld this decision, stating that Ziklag was collaterally estopped from challenging the district court’s ruling that it lacked the right to sue for past damages. The court emphasized that all necessary factors for collateral estoppel were met, preventing Ziklag from relitigating the issue of its standing to claim past damages. ([law.justia.com](https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/cafc/25-1733/25-1733-2026-11-19.html?utm_source=openai))
In the separate case against Netflix, the district court also dismissed the lawsuit, finding that Ziklag lacked the right to sue for past infringement. Ziklag sought to amend the complaint to reinstate Touchmusic as the plaintiff, arguing that Touchmusic had retained the right to sue for past damages and had restored its corporate status. However, the district court denied this request, concluding that the substitution was made for tactical advantage rather than due to an honest mistake. The Federal Circuit affirmed this decision, agreeing that the request to amend was made in bad faith. ([law.justia.com](https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/cafc/25-1960/25-1960-2026-11-19.html?utm_source=openai))
These rulings underscore the importance of proper legal standing and the implications of corporate status in patent litigation. They also highlight the challenges associated with enforcing rights over expired patents, particularly when assignments do not explicitly convey the right to sue for past damages.